The following excerpt is taken from Chapter Six of
Non-Hodgkin's Lymphomas: Making Sense of Diagnosis, Treatment, and
Options by Lorraine Johnston, copyright 1999 by O'Reilly & Associates,
Inc. For book orders/information, call 1-800-998-9938. Permission is
granted to print and distribute this excerpt for noncommercial use as
long as the above source is included. The information in this article is
meant to educate and should not be used as an alternative for
professional medical care.
This article will not outline which treatment is best for you, as such
information changes continually with treatment, research, and
time. Nor will this article discuss rare treatments used outside the
U.S. and Canada or treatments classified as alternative. Rather, we
list generally accepted standards of care for broad classes of NHL at
the time the book this article is exerted from was written. These
descriptions are provided to give you an overview of treatments and a
starting point to find out more about the treatments your doctors
recommend for you.
The information in this article is drawn from the National Cancer
Institute's non-Hodgkin's lymphoma state-of-the-art treatment
statements for physicians, and is supplemented from various sources,
such as the second edition of Magrath's The Non-Hodgkin's
Lymphomas, as well as current research papers.
Knowing your classification, grade, and staging information gives you
a way to compare your diagnosis and recommended treatment to reports
in the literature or descriptions of clinical trials. It also gives
you the vocabulary you need to speak with medical professionals who
might not already be familiar with your case.
Many attempts have been made to categorize the NHLs in a way that
is meaningful to the treatment chosen and the best
outcome. Nonetheless, owing to the variety of ways NHL can manifest, a
unified system has yet to be agreed upon.
You should ask your oncologist about your classification and
grading information, about which classification system was used--Kiel,
Working Formulation, the REAL system, or some amalgam of these--and
obtain a copy of your pathology reports.
Because there is such disparity about classifying the NHLs, you
should not become alarmed if a treatment described in this article as
appropriate for another classification is recommended for yours.
This article includes the following sections:
Most low-grade NHLs, also called indolent NHLs, if found in the
earliest stages--many are not found until quite advanced--are
small-cell and follicular, that is, occurring only within the
follicles of lymph nodes. Exceptions include the low-grade MALT
lymphomas that occur outside lymph nodes in other lymphoid tissue such
as the stomach and salivary glands.
Low-grade disease usually progresses slowly at first. As time
passes, it may convert to a more aggressive disease with larger cell
appearance and diffuse involvement of the entire lymph node instead of
just the follicle. This is called diffuse disease within the
node, but please note that the term "diffuse" may also be used to
describe a wider spread of disease throughout the body, or may be used
to describe certain types of bone marrow involvement.
It's possible for low-grade and higher-grade disease to coexist in
the same patient or even within the same node, and when this is seen,
it may be assumed by some practitioners to be a transition to a higher
grade and is treated as a higher-grade disease.
It is much more common to find low-grade disease in adults than in children.
The National Cancer Institute recommends that all patients with
low-grade disease should consider enrolling in a clinical trial. Many
treatments in use today for low-grade disease result in remission,
even in long remission, but usually these are not lasting
remissions. By examining clinical trials, you may gain access to
newer, better treatments years before they are made available to the
general public. You and your oncologist should discuss the advantages
and disadvantages of this option.
Low-grade disease may be treated with one of the monoclonal
antibodies that sense particular cell surface proteins, such as
Rituxan, which was approved by the FDA in November 1997, and is
specific for the CD20 cell surface antigen.
A watch-and-wait approach may be suggested by your
oncologist. This consists of watching for certain blood values to
change, for nodes to enlarge, for other organs to become involved, or
for the cell type to shift to a more aggressive grade. Visits for
examination and testing, including blood tests, CT scans, and perhaps
marrow biopsies, may be scheduled every three to six months, or
oftener, depending on your individual circumstances. This posture is
adopted because studies of those treated with chemotherapy in early
stages of low-grade NHL have not shown an overall increase in survival
over those who wait until disease is more symptomatic to start
treatment. As many people with low-grade NHL can live for twelve years
or more, five-year survival statistics following treatment must be
interpreted very carefully. Ten- or fifteen-year survival statistics
are more meaningful.
Low-grade disease may or may not exhibit symptoms initially. If
symptoms are present and serious, immediate treatment may be called
for.
One survivor describes why some NHL survivors of low-grade disease
call "watchful waiting" by another name, "watch and worry":
I can tell you it is unnerving at best not knowing when, where, or
how "the beast" will strike. I wake up every day and think, "Is today
the day?" When it's time for a doctor visit or a CT scan, I think,
"Have the nodes grown? Is this the visit when my doctor will tell me
it's time for treatment?"
And just try to explain to outsiders that you have cancer, but are
receiving no treatment. Outsiders are sometimes confused--sometimes
they believe you're "too far gone" for treatment. You can see a look
of doom come over their faces. This can be frightening or funny,
depending on who's doing it, when, and so on.
For those on watch-and-wait before treatment, there's an eerie
aspect concerning our denial. There are moments when we can pretend
not to be sick, and we do such a good job of denying our illness that
when a node suddenly grows, or when the doctor says it's time for
treatment, we feel foolish and betrayed.
Many research centers are studying the effect of bone marrow or
stem cell transplantation on low-grade disease.
Stage I or contiguous stage II low-grade disease
This stage, usually symptomless, can be treated, and might
possibly be cured, with local radiation or surgery.
Additional treatments that might be recommended:
- Single chemotherapeutic agent such as fludarabine or chlorambucil.
- Interferon.
- Monoclonal antibodies.
Stage II noncontiguous or stages III/IV low-grade disease
Treatment that might be recommended:
- Single-agent chemotherapeutic agents such as 2-CDA,
cyclophosphamide, chlorambucil, or fludarabine.
- Combination chemotherapy, such as CVP or CHOP.
- Surgery to remove the spleen (splenectomy) if the spleen is affected.
- Radiotherapy to selected locations.
- Monoclonal antibodies.
- Bone marrow transplantation.
Recurrent low-grade disease
If low-grade disease relapses to a higher grade, treatment is
geared to its grade. For relapses that remain low-grade, one of the
treatments described in the preceding sections usually is used.
The aggressive NHLs include a large group categorized as
intermediate- or high-grade disease: low-grade disease converting to a
higher grade, lymphoblastic lymphoma, angiocentric lymphoma,
angioblastic lymphoma, immunoblastic lymphoma, Burkitt's or the
Burkitt-like small noncleaved lymphomas, true histiocytic lymphoma,
viral-associated adult T-cell lymphoma/leukemia, and others.
Not surprisingly, the most important determinant in treating the
aggressive NHLs is the subtype being treated, some of which have quite
specific therapies. An accurate diagnosis is mandatory for selecting
the right treatment.
In addition to this general information, see separate discussions
later in this article for lymphoblastic, small noncleaved (Burkitt's
and Burkitt-like), large-cell, MALT, cutaneous T-cell, and extranodal
lymphomas.
Stage I or contiguous stage II aggressive disease
According to the National Cancer Institute's PDQ
State-of-the-Art Treatment Statement for Adult NHL, studies
have shown that long-term survival or cure is achieved more often if
both chemotherapy and radiation therapy are used for this stage of
disease, in spite of its relatively limited spread. Usually CHOP or a
related regimen is used, but important differences in treatment exist
for many aggressive lymphomas such as the large-cell, lymphoblastic,
and small noncleaved cell lymphomas, which are discussed separately
later in this article.
Your doctor may determine that chemotherapy alone, or radiotherapy
alone, is more appropriate for your circumstances than combined
chemotherapy and radiotherapy.
Stage II noncontiguous or stages III / IV aggressive disease
Because at these stages disease usually is more widely distributed
through the body, combination chemotherapy alone usually is
recommended, without radiation, as radiotherapy doses to multiple
sites for widespread disease would be too toxic. There may be
instances, however, when local radiotherapy is needed to reduce tumor
size in one location.
Usually CHOP or a related regimen is used, but important
differences in treatment exist for many aggressive lymphomas such as
the large-cell, lymphoblastic, and small noncleaved cell lymphomas,
which are discussed separately later in this article.
Patients at high risk of relapse might be advised to consider
autologous or allogeneic bone marrow transplantation.
Other chemotherapeutic regimens used
Some studies have shown that, for many of the aggressive NHLs that
respond to anthracycline-based therapies like CHOP, other
chemotherapeutic regimens have not emerged as clearly superior to
CHOP, but more than forty such similar regimens in addition to CHOP
are recorded in the medical literature. Often, alternate regimens
containing some of the same drugs used in CHOP are used for a variety
of reasons tailored to the specific patient.
Bill's story
Bill is a survivor of high-grade NHL who was treated with both
chemotherapy and radiation therapy. He describes his treatment and the
side effects, and offers encouragement that the discomfort is
temporary:
I was diagnosed April 1, 1996. I had a swollen neck gland and the
back of my tongue had a huge hump on it. The ear, nose, and throat
(ENT) doctor took a piece off the back of my tongue, sent me over for
x-rays and a CT scan (both negative, by the way). I went back to the
ENT doctor in two days and he gave me the news: large B-cell NHL,
diffuse. I then went to an oncologist friend who I had known for
twenty-five years, though not professionally. He did bone marrow
studies, a spinal fluid analysis, more CT scans, all kinds of blood
work, and put me to sleep for a gastroenterology look-see ... all
negative, so he staged it IIA, high grade.
The tumors completely disappeared with the first CHOP (plus
VP-16) treatment, which was administered three days running, every
third week.
I do recall several times just feeling so bad during
treatment. Not nausea or digestive sickness, but just sick. Just about
the sickest I've ever been. But it did pass in a few days.
After the third of these treatments, I suffered a heart attack,
but ended up with minimal to no damage. I had two stents implanted in
my right coronary artery. I did nicely with that.
After seven CHOP treatments, I had radiation to the neck area
every day for four weeks. I was left with very painful yet numb feet,
and tingling in my left arm, which is still there. The neurologist has
not found an answer to that. He says numbness results from
vincristine, but it ought not to hurt.
Rest assured that I was so sick several times that death would
have been a relief (not really, but it felt like it).
One last thing: I did not taper off the prednisone dose, and I
have since felt that the precipitous drop in dosage may have been
responsible for the sickness. But, while taking it for those five
days, I was king of the world, fit to be tied, a bundle of
energy--though that got to be less and less with each session.
Take it easy. Easier said than done, I know, but just recognize
the fact that you will not feel well some of the time.
This form of lymphoma, usually found in children and young adults,
is rapid and aggressive, and often resembles acute lymphoblastic
leukemia.
Treatment is begun as soon as possible. If disease has already
spread as indicated by staging at levels III or IV, the same highly
successful approach that is used for acute lymphoblastic leukemia
(ALL) may be used, involving two to three years of treatment, and
precautionary treatment of the central nervous system. This treatment
is divided into three phases: induction of remission, consolidation of
remission, and maintenance. Each phase uses different drugs and timing
to eradicate all disease. In adults, areas of bulky tumor involvement
may be irradiated to reduce tumor mass.
It is possible for this form of NHL to lodge in the central
nervous system. Treatment to kill all cells that may be lingering
there might be recommended, consisting of either cranial and spinal
irradiation or methotrexate injected into cerebrospinal fluid.
Postremission therapy, called maintenance, which improves the
survival odds in this form of NHL, may include short-term intense
chemotherapy, longer, less intense chemotherapy, or bone marrow
transplantation.
Stage I / II
Several treatment regimens produce good results against early
stage lymphoblastic lymphoma. Treatments that might be recommended
include:
- Vincristine, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, prednisone,
mercaptopurine, methotrexate.
- CHOP alternating with infusional methotrexate.
- COMP.
- LMT 81: LSA2L2 plus methotrexate.
- For adults, CHOP plus methotrexate, 6-MP, and l-asparaginase are
sometimes used.
Stage III
The National Cancer Institute recommends that patients with a
large anterior mediastinal (chest) tumor should consider clinical
trials, because of the risks associated with superior vena cava
syndrome and with treating such a large tumor in this location.
If the tumor is pressing on the superior vena cava, low-dose
radiation may be used to shrink the tumor.
Treatment that might be recommended:
- LSA2L2, a multi-phase treatment consisting of induction,
consolidation, and maintenance.
- LSA2L2 plus high-dose methotrexate.
- CHOP, alternating with methotrexate.
- ACOP+.
- BFM, a multi-phase treatment consisting of induction,
consolidation, and maintenance.
- LMT 81: LSA2L2 plus methotrexate.
- Addition of VM-26 (teniposide) and ARA-C (cytarabine) to
multi-phase therapies such as LSA2L2.
- For adults, CHOP plus methotrexate, 6-MP, and l-asparaginase are
sometimes used.
Stage IV
Although there are several FDA-approved treatment options
available for this stage of disease, the National Cancer Institute
recommends that all patients at this stage should consider entering a
clinical trial to take advantage of the foremost improvements in
treatment.
If you have disseminated lymphoblastic lymphoma, treatment for
possible spread to the central nervous system should be considered.
Compression of the superior vena cava may be treated with low-dose radiation.
Treatment that might be recommended:
- LSA2L2, a multi-phase treatment consisting of induction,
consolidation, and maintenance.
- LSA2L2 plus high-dose methotrexate.
- BFM, a multi-phase treatment consisting of induction,
consolidation, and maintenance.
- LMT 81: LSA2L2 plus methotrexate.
- Addition of VM-26 (teniposide) and ARA-C (cytarabine) to
multi-phase therapies such as LSA2L2.
- For adults, CHOP plus methotrexate, 6-MP, and l-asparaginase are
sometimes used.
Relapsed disease
How relapse is treated depends on what treatments were used in the
past, and where the disease has recurred. Clinical trials, intensive
regimens, other regimens containing drugs not previously used, and
bone marrow transplantation are possible choices you should discuss
with your doctor.
This category includes Burkitt's as well as the Burkitt-like lymphomas.
Treatment for adults and children is similar, and may include
brief, intensive combination chemotherapy, with or without radiation.
Surgical removal of disease in the abdomen may be advantageous if
the tumor can be completely removed.
Stage I / II
Treatment that might be recommended:
- COMP.
- CHOP.
- CHOP plus methotrexate.
- BFM 86.
- High-intensity, brief-duration treatment: cyclophosphamide,
etoposide, vincristine, bleomycin, methotrexate, doxorubicin,
allopurinol, and prednisone.
- ARA-C, high-dose methotrexate, ifosfamide, and etoposide also may
be used if bone marrow or central nervous system involvement is found.
Stage III / IV
Although there are several FDA-approved treatment options
available for this stage of disease, the National Cancer Institute
recommends that all patients at this stage should consider entering a
clinical trial to take advantage of the foremost improvements in
treatment.
Treatment that might be recommended:
- French LMB-89.
- Total B (St. Jude's).
- BFM 86.
- ARA-C, high-dose methotrexate, ifosfamide, and etoposide also may
be used if bone marrow or central nervous system involvement is found.
- High-intensity, brief-duration treatment: cyclophosphamide,
etoposide, vincristine, bleomycin, methotrexate, doxorubicin,
allopurinol, and prednisone.
- For stage IV, modified "total B": cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin,
vincristine, methotrexate, cytarabine.
Recurrent disease
How relapse is treated depends on what treatments were used in the
past and where the disease has recurred. Clinical trials, aggressive
or intensive regimens, other regimens containing drugs not previously
used, and bone marrow transplantation are possible choices you should
discuss with your doctor.
Several types of large-cell lymphomas are found in both adults and
children. These include Ki-1 anaplastic large-cell lymphoma (ALCL),
and centroblastic and immunoblastic lymphomas.
Stage I / II
Treatment that might be recommended, depending on subtype:
- COMP.
- CHOP.
- MACOP-B may be recommended for mediastinal disease.
Stage III / IV
Treatment that might be recommended, depending on subtype:
- APO.
- ACOP or ACOP+.
- COMP.
- CHOP.
- MACOP-B may be recommended for mediastinal disease.
- The Milan protocol.
- NHL-BFM 86/90.
- POG 8106.
- LSA2L2, as used for acute lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma.
Recurrent disease
How relapse is treated depends on what treatments were used in the
past, and where the disease has recurred. Clinical trials, aggressive
or intensive regimens, other regimens containing drugs not previously
used, treatment using regimens tested under stage III or IV small
noncleaved cell lymphoma, and bone marrow transplantation are possible
choices you should discuss with your doctor.
This form of NHL arises in about 3 percent of those who test
positive for the virus known as HTLV-I, human T-Cell lymphotropic
virus. It's found among IV drug users in many parts of the world, and
among those living in parts of Japan and parts of the Caribbean. A
smaller number of infected population also is found in the
southeastern U.S.
Treatments that might be recommended are:
- Pentostatin (deoxycoformycin) plus interferon-beta or IFN-gamma.
- Monoclonal antibodies that target CD25-positive B-cells.
- Antivirals such as zidovudine plus interferon-alfa.
MALT lymphomas arise in the mucosa-associated lymphoid tissues,
such as the stomach, tonsils, thyroid, or parts of the small
intestine. MALT lymphomas may be low-grade or aggressive, but are
usually low-grade.
The gastric MALT lymphomas, which comprise the bulk of the MALT
lymphomas, usually are associated with infection by the bacteria
Helicobacter pylori and may respond to treatment with
antibiotics. If they do not, generally single-agent chemotherapeutic
drugs are attempted.
A few studies have shown a possible link between H. pylori
and MALT lymphoma in the lung.
Other sites of disease, such as the thyroid, might be treated with
surgery followed by chemotherapy.
Enteropathy-associated T-cell MALT lymphoma, which is linked to
inherited celiac disease, dermatitis herpetiformis, and possibly to
Epstein-Barr virus, might be treated with surgery.
Monocytoid B-cell MALT lymphoma might be treated with the COP,
CHOP, ABVD, or m-BACOD regimens.
Other MALT lymphomas, such as those of the lung, pharynx, salivary
gland, stomach, thyroid, or immunoproliferative small intestine
disease (IPSID) may be approached with combination chemotherapies such
as COP, CHOP, or CVD in addition to surgeries or antibiotic
treatments.
Malignancies that arise in Waldeyer's Ring, consisting of the
nasopharynx, tonsils, and the base of the tongue, are considered by
some researchers to be nodal NHLs, but by others to be MALT NHLs, and
will be treated according to the physician's beliefs. (Note that two
tonsils remain after tonsillectomy, at the base of the tongue and at
the back of the roof of the mouth.)
Cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, also called mycosis fungoides, begins
as low-grade disease and may entail a long survival time of twenty
years or more. It may progress beyond skin involvement (Sezary
syndrome) to a more serious and rapid disease. Cutaneous T-cell
lymphoma is treated in different ways, depending on how much of the
body is affected.
This form of lymphoma should not be confused with peripheral
T-cell lymphoma, adult T-cell leukemia/lymphoma, or anaplastic
large-cell lymphoma, which are higher-grade lymphomas that also may
present in the skin and are treated with therapies suitable for
high-grade disease.
Many treatments are geared to cutaneous lymphoma still found only
in the skin:
- Radiotherapy.
- Total skin electron beam therapy (TSEBT).
- Local electron-beam irradiation.
- Orthovoltage radiation therapy.
- Carbon dioxide laser.
- Light therapy.
- Psoralen/PUVA light therapy.
- Extracorporeal photochemotherapy (photopheresis): blood circulated
through a pheresis machine (ECPP).
- Phototherapy with ultraviolet B in clinical trials.
- Topical medications.
- Mechlorethamine (nitrogen mustard).
- Carmustine (BCNU).
- Retinoids (etretinate).
- Phosphocholines (hexadecylphosphocholine).
Disease that has spread to other organs might be treated with
multiple agents, combined with skin treatments above, perhaps
including:
- Interferon alfa.
- Monoclonal antibodies.
- Systemic (whole-body oral or IV) chemotherapies such as
fludarabine, 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine (2-CDA), pentostatin, chlorambucil
and prednisone, cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, or combinations of
these and other chemotherapeutic agents.
Relapses might be treated with recombinations of the treatments
listed above, with bone marrow transplantation, or with novel
approaches available through clinical trials.
Disease that has not spread from elsewhere, but instead has arisen
outside a lymph node or lymphatic organ, requires a specialized
approach depending on the location of the disease. This appearance of
an NHL is called "primary disease in an extranodal site," and
characterizes several of both the low-grade and aggressive lymphomas.
Owing to the great number of extranodal sites in which an NHL can
arise, a detailed outline of standard treatments for each site cannot
be given here. Magrath's The Non-Hodgkin's Lymphomas and
current research papers and NCI treatment statements are your best
sources for information about the rare primary extranodal NHLs.
The tissues comprising Waldeyer's Ring--the base of the tongue,
the palatine, sublingual, and pharyngeal tonsils (the latter two are
not removed during tonsillectomy), the nasopharynx, and the
larynx--are considered by many researchers to be either nodal or MALT
lymphomas rather than extranodal sites, as these tissues are lymphatic
tissue. For these sites, see the descriptions of treatment for
low-grade, aggressive, or MALT diseases earlier in this article.
Other extranodal NHLs, such as certain intestinal NHLs, also may
be determined to be MALT lymphomas if they arise in the
mucosa-associated lymphoid tissues.
Primary lymphoma of bone is distinct from lymphoma that has arisen
elsewhere and traveled to bone marrow.
Each extranodal presentation is treated in a highly individualized
way with chemotherapy, radiotherapy, or a combination of the two.