The following excerpt is taken from Chapter 6 of
Bipolar Disorders: A Guide to Helping Children and Adolescents
by Mitzi Walsh, copyright 2000 by
O'Reilly & Associates, Inc. For book orders/information, call
(800) 998-9938. Permission is granted to print and distribute this
excerpt for noncommercial use as long as the above source is
included. The information in this article is meant to educate and
should not be used as an alternative for professional medical care.
Alternative treatments may be suggested by your family doctor or psychiatrist,
or by a specialist in a particular type of treatment. The most common types of
alternative medical practices are explained in the following sections:
Developed in China, acupuncture is based on the idea that an energy force
called ch'i flows through the human body. If your ch'i is
blocked, as acupuncture theory states, illness results. Modern acupuncturists
use tiny, sterile, disposable needles inserted into the skin to undo these
blockages. Some also employ heat, (noninvasive) lasers, magnetic devices, or
electrical stimulation.
You don't have to believe in the ch'i concept to enjoy the benefits
of acupuncture. Even the alternative medicine skeptics at the National
Institutes of Health admit that it has value for treating chronic pain, and as
an adjunct to other methods in the treatment of drug addiction (in fact, NIH is
currently funding several studies on acupuncture). Some Western doctors think
that acupuncture may work by influencing the body's production of natural opioid
chemicals and neurotransmitters.
Reputable research indicates that properly applied acupuncture treatments may
help heal nerve damage, which may in turn reduce anxiety and mood swings. There
have been anecdotal reports from bipolar adults about acupuncture as an
effective treatment for manic episodes (actress Margot Kidder, who has bipolar I
disorder, claimed to have been successfully treated by an acupuncturist after a
much-publicized manic/psychotic episode a few years ago). If you can find a good
acupuncturist, it might be a worthwhile adjunct to other types of medical
care.
Before the advent of modern medicine, people everywhere relied on herbal
remedies. India's Ayurveda and traditional Chinese medicine (which also includes
acupuncture) are two herbal systems that have been studied to a great extent.
The Ayurvedic medicine concept revolves around a life-force called
prana, which is comparable to the Chinese ch'i mentioned
previously.
Ayurvedic practitioners will give you a thorough exam and tell you which
"type" you are in their diagnostic system. Then they'll suggest an
appropriate diet, lifestyle adjustments, and probably meditation. They may also
have various suggestions about cleaning out your digestive tract, and may
prescribe herbal remedies.
Chinese traditional medicine practitioners take a very similar approach,
although their dietary recommendations tend to be less strict than a typical
Ayurvedic plan. They may recommend physical and breathing exercises as well as
herbs.
There is a vast array of Ayurvedic and Chinese herbal remedies available,
most of which have not been tested by Western researchers. Some of these
concoctions are probably quite effective, while others could be dangerous to
your health. Try to find out exactly which herbs are in a remedy, and then check
out their known effects in a reference book on herbs. For example, the popular
Chinese herb Ma Huang (ephedra) is a common ingredient in traditional
"nerve tonics." It is also a powerful central nervous system
stimulant, and should be taken with caution.
Chiropractors use their hands or special equipment to make
"adjustments" to the spine and related body structures. This is useful
for some people with back pain, and sometimes appears to help with other
disorders.
There is no scientific reason for chiropractic adjustments to alleviate the
symptoms of bipolar disorders, but some people have reported symptom reduction.
There could be something about chiropractic and the nervous system that's yet to
be discovered.
"Bodywork" is a general term that covers a wide variety of
therapeutic practices. Most of them involve massaging, manipulating, or moving
the muscles and body parts in specific ways. These practices differ in style,
intensity, and intent, and include:
-
Acupressure. Similar to acupuncture, it employs firm or light pressure
applied to specific sites on the body rather than needles. Acupressure does have
a track record in helping with chronic pain and some physical disorders. Its
efficacy for bipolar symptoms is unknown.
-
Massage. There are many forms, including Swedish, Shiatsu (which resembles
acupressure), and more. It can promote relaxation, physical comfort, and body
awareness. It may also help decrease sensory defensiveness. Its efficacy for
other bipolar symptoms is unknown.
-
The Feldenkrais Method. Developed by Moshe Feldenkrais, this concentrates on
rebuilding sensory and movement systems, particularly through unlearning poor
movement patterns. A number of Feldenkrais practitioners work with children who
have neurological problems. The therapy is gentle, and some children have
experienced gross-motor, fine-motor, sensory, and relational improvements. A
variant called Feldenkrais for Children with Neurological Disorders (FCND) is
specially geared toward this population. The efficiency of Feldenkrais for
bipolar symptoms is unknown. For more information on FCND, see the
Movement Educators web site.
-
Craniosacral therapy. Involves delicately manipulating the plates of the
skull and the "cranial tides" of the body. Some may question the
scientific basis of craniosacral work, but it is gentle, noninvasive, and
parents of many children with neurological problems say it has been helpful.
Most craniosacral therapists employ a certain amount of talk therapy along with
the bodywork, which may or may not appeal to your child. Its efficacy for
bipolar symptoms is unknown. Although it was developed by osteopath John
Upledger, craniosacral therapy is practiced by trained members of other
professions, including some occupational therapists and physical therapists.
Upledger includes some accounts of beneficial use of this therapy for people
with mental illness in his book Your Inner Physician and You: Craniosacral
Therapy and Somatoemotional Release (1997, North Atlantic Books). For more
information, see the Craniosacral Therapy web site.
-
The Alexander Technique. Used to help patients streamline and increase the
gracefulness of their movements. Practitioners teach patients new, more balanced
movement patterns. Since self-awareness is an important part of this approach,
the Alexander Technique is probably more applicable to teenagers and adults than
to children. Its efficacy for bipolar symptoms is unknown. For more information,
see the Alexander
Technique web site.
Some bodywork believers make extravagant claims. For any bodywork method,
including those not mentioned here, check the practitioner's credentials, and
make sure you feel comfortable with both the person and the methodology.
All of the modalities listed here have accrediting bodies in most Western
countries. Generally speaking, accredited, well-trained practitioners are more
likely to do beneficial work than self-trained or non-accredited
practitioners.
If you happen to be near a massage school or a training center for another
bodywork method, inexpensive classes may be available. Some schools also operate
free or low-cost clinics that allow students to practice on patients under close
supervision.
Naturopaths are licensed to practice medicine in some countries, and also in
some US states and Canadian provinces. They use the designation ND rather than
MD. Their focus is on preventive and holistic healthcare.
Naturopaths vary in their personal philosophy about Western medicine. Some
will refer patients to an MD for ailments they feel are out of their league,
others prefer to rely only on nutritional and natural medicine.
When Lili was 13, she saw a naturopath a few times who tried to treat her with
B-vitamin injections and a better diet. It seemed to clear up her constant
bronchial symptoms a bit and brighten her mood, but the effects wore off
quickly. On the other hand, the herbal remedy he gave her for a urinary tract
infection worked as well as any pharmaceutical I've ever seen. --Sarah, mother
of 17-year-old Lili (diagnosed bipolar II disorder, OCD)
Be careful when you choose an ND. In the US, some people calling themselves
naturopaths have not completed an accredited program. Properly licensed
naturopaths receive medical training that is roughly comparable to traditional
medical school, but with a different emphasis.
For information about finding a licensed naturopath in the US or Canada,
contact the American
Association of Naturopathic Physicians or the
Canadian Naturopathic Association.
Technically, a holistic psychologist should have the same credentials as a
regular psychologist, plus training in holistic health-promotion practices. In
practice, this may not be the case, so be sure to ask. Depending on the
practitioner, holistic psychology would appear to be of significant value to
people with bipolar disorders who would like to combine talk therapy with
alternative healthcare practices.
A holistic psychologist might recommend a combination of dietary changes,
nutritional supplements, exercise, biofeedback, and mood control techniques,
such as meditation or self-hypnosis. Helping the patient build an effective
support system should also be part of the plan. These interventions would have
the overall goal of helping to normalize physical health, improve mental
stability, and help the patient have a more enjoyable and productive life.
Homeopathy is based on the principle that remedies containing infinitesimal
amounts of substances that could cause the medical condition being treated can
instead prod the immune system into action against the condition. Homeopathy is
considered to be fairly mainstream in the UK.
In the US and Canada, homeopathic physicians are not licensed to practice
medicine. However, some MDs and NDs do recommend homeopathic treatments, and a
few homeopaths are also fully licensed medical or naturopathic doctors. For
information about homeopaths in North America, see the
National Center for
Homeopathy web site.
Homeopathy does not seem to have a good track record as an intervention for
bipolar disorders, although some patients report that certain homeopathic
remedies can occasionally provide relief from anxiety and physical distress
associated with mood swings. Most mainstream physicians believe that homeopathic
remedies contain too little of the active ingredient to have any medical effect.
That said, homeopathic remedies are also too diluted to cause any harm, and it's
a well-known fact that if you believe a placebo will help, you may actually
experience a reduction in symptoms.
Nutritionists are experts in how food intake affects health. Some are
employed by hospitals, clinics, and long-term care facilities to improve patient
care through appropriate diet. Others work in private practice. Some
nutritionists have very traditional views about diet, while others may recommend
what seem like radical changes. Be sure to check the credentials and training of
any nutritionist you consult, and pay attention to your intuition if her
suggestions seem unreasonable or potentially unhealthy.
If your child has an eating disorder in addition to a bipolar disorder, a
nutritionist with background in dietary interventions for these disorders should
definitely be part of your treatment team. You may also want to consult a
nutritionist about dietary changes that could be beneficial, such as the special
diets mentioned later in this chapter.
The most famous proponent of orthomolecular medicine was its late founder,
Dr. Linus Pauling. Better known for receiving the 1954 Nobel Prize for Chemistry
and the 1962 Nobel Prize for Peace, Pauling spent most of his later life
studying and publicizing the effects of megadoses of vitamins, particularly
vitamin C. Many of Dr. Pauling's more extravagant claims have not been
substantiated by research, but his reputation forced the medical establishment
to take his ideas seriously.
Some MDs, NDs, nutritionists, and other practitioners are firm believers in
orthomolecular medicine, and Pauling's principles underlie many of the megadose
vitamin concoctions on health food store shelves. Since large doses of vitamins
can have side effects as well as potential benefits, be sure to talk with your
doctor about what to watch out for and how any benefits will be assessed. You
definitely shouldn't do megadose vitamin therapy without consulting a competent
professional first.
Osteopaths operate somewhat like chiropractors, adjusting the musculoskeletal
system to effect improvement. In the UK, licensed osteopaths participate in the
National Health scheme. Osteopaths are licensed to practice medicine in all US
states, and use the initials DO (Doctor of Osteopathy) instead of MD.
One area of osteopathy-related treatment, craniosacral therapy, is often
recommended for children with neurological challenges.